Safe Mode: On
Prison contractor says stop whining

Even jurors teared up listening to how the then-24-year-old begged nurses, corrections officers and a physicians assistant for help because he couldn't feel his legs after a week of back pain and a month after being diagnosed with a staph infection.

After Fields finally went to the hospital, a neurosurgeon operated and discovered a methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus abscess on his spine, which caused permanent paralysis. Fields today has a wobbly gait and his legs below the knees are the width of a man's forearms.

Jurors are expected to hear closing arguments and begin deliberating this morning at the federal courthouse in Fort Myers.

Fields, 28, sued Prison Health Services, the company that contracts with the Lee County Sheriff to provide health care in the jail, and former physician's assistant Joseph Richards Jr. and former nurse Bettie Joyce Allen. He's seeking unspecified damages. He was booked into the Lee County Jail on July 7, 2007, on misdemeanor charges of criminal mischief, contempt of court and a probation violation.

"I'm angry because nobody that I talked to, not a single person, about every individual I talked to, brushed me off like I wasn't important - like asking for help didn't matter to them," Fields told jurors. "My whole life was taken from me."

Fields can walk, but a doctor testified he will eventually form severe arthritis and require hip, knee and ankle replacements. For eight months after his August 2007 surgery, he was in a wheelchair. He then upgraded to a walker and taught himself to ride a bicycle and can now walk independently. He testified he couldn't afford physical therapy shortly after his release from jail because he was denied Medicare and Medicaid.

Fields saw Richards on Aug. 8 and, after complaining of back pain and telling him he couldn't feel his legs, Richards prescribed Tylenol and a followup a week later after a muscle strain diagnosis. At 1:30 a.m. Aug. 9, inmates screaming "man down" caused nurse supervisor Allen to come to the cell.

After Fields said he couldn't feel his legs and his "insides" came out attempting to use the bathroom, Allen diagnosed him with hemorrhoids, pushed the hemorrhoids back in and ordered a doctor's visit for the morning. It was Lee County Jail's chief doctor, Noel Dominguez, who examined Fields and sent him to the hospital.

"I told him, 'Thank you - that he probably saved my life,'" Fields testified before breaking down in tears, "that he actually took the time to see me."

In a recorded deposition read aloud Wednesday, Allen testified during monthly meetings with nursing staff, Prison Health Services officials stressed not sending inmates to hospitals because of prior mistakes and the cost to the company. She said nurses needed to call doctors for clearance. Miami doctor Arthur Fournier, the defense's only witness, testified Thursday that Richards and Allen provided proper care under the circumstances.

"The nurse's job is to triage, not to diagnose," he said of Allen. "Her judgement was that it was not an emergency and that he could wait to be seen until the morning. It was appropriate."

http://www.news-press.com/article/20110318/NEWS0110/103180411/1085/NEWS0110/Ex-inmate-shares-painful-ordeal


Click to view image: 'cf86c6b24a3b-privateprisonindustry.jpeg'

Added: Mar-28-2011 
By: Nurb
In:
News, LiveLeaks
Tags: private, prison, industry, medical, nurses, neglect, contractor, profit
Marked as: approved
Views: 7355 | Comments: 30 | Votes: 2 | Favorites: 0 | Shared: 0 | Updates: 0 | Times used in channels: 1
You need to be registered in order to add comments! Register HERE
Sort by: Newest first | Oldest first | Highest score first
Liveleak opposes racial slurs - if you do spot comments that fall into this category, please report them for us to review.
  • Permanent injury and willfull neglect over a misdemeanor? I hope this guy takes the company for all its worth. Private prison bullshit.

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (11)

    • Like a government run prison is any better? This prison management team is toast. They are going to jail or otherwise out of business. Other private prisons will take note and take steps to preserve their own profits. In private business, you pull sh.t like this and you're done. The story doesn't stipulate the damages sought, but corporate structure cannot protect management individuals from personal liability in a case like this.

      Government prisons get what? They get taxpayer bailouts an More..

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (0)

    • I agree. Especially in California, state prison guards have been awarded overly generous contracts that are costing the state a fortune. State can't afford it so they want to contract out to private firms. With all the overtime being paid, 1 out of 10 guards is making $100,000 or more.

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (1)

    • Government ran prisons are better. Do you know how the stock is traded on private prisons on Wall Street? It's value is based on the number of incarcerated citizens. THINK about that one for a minute. Fucking disgusting.

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (3)

    • You and nurb amaze me. Privately run prisons don't commit the crime, they don't try the perps, they don't sit in the jury, they don't issue any judgements, and they don't pronounce the sentences. They house prisoners according to the punishment the criminal justice system decrees. If they are trading well on wall street, that means they are doing a good job at a price better than the government can do. They don't go out on the streets and snatch anyone.

      Look at the other side of the coin. More..

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (-3)

    • You are overlooking a few facts here, one there have been a number of cases from Juvenal court and adult court of the Private Prisons corrupting Judges to increase incarcerations and the duration of incarcerations for minor offenses. You are also overlooking that it costs 3 times more for us and our tax dollars to pay for private prisons. You area also looking over that they benefit from not rehabilitating inmates to insure more repeat offenders. You are also overlooking that their bottom line i More..

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (2)

  • Agreed, that is BS. Under normal circumstances, this would easily be deemed malpractice. I hope he gets a decent settlement soon.

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (8)

  • this can happend to anyone of us.

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (6)

  • prisons should NEVER be privatized.the state hands out punishment,not some moneygrubbing fat cat

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (6)

  • Comment of user '2daloo' has been deleted by author!
  • Comment of user '' has been deleted by moderator!
    • the private prisons cost the taxpayers more money than federal though, so we're still getting robbed and they are motivated by repeat offenders making them money, offering little to no rehabilitation to increase the chances.

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (11)

    • And then you have corruption in the court system to keep this scheme going.

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (6)

  • there is a difference between sentencing and punishment

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (0)

  • I'm speechless. We just don't have anything to talk about.

    1. The government is accountable. That would be why we have Obamacare, still pay the UN, endure MASSIVE waste and fraud in various and sundry social programs, and stand by while the revolving political doors funnel jillions to special interest groups like illegals, acorn etc etc etc.

    2. This is as far as I got in your response. I asked for any one government program that got things done cheaper than the private sector. And your r More..

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (0)

    • Of course those are paid for by a large pool of taxes, but the SERVICE to the individual is free rental and cheap mailing. You asked what service, I gave you one.

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (0)

    • Did you actually proof read what you just wrote? Seriously, only a blazing, incoherent lib would make such a statement. I mean that in the most pejorative way possible. This is a joke, right?

      Just where in the hell do you think that "large pool of taxes" comes from there Sparky? And then, just for shits and grins, you then follow that statement with the "service to the individual is free and cheap." Damn that's stupid. That kind of talk is precisely what is wrong with More..

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (0)

    • I was going to post the numbers but I noticed there are equal studies that conflict on both sides of this. There are some studies that show private prisons are cost effective and then there are those that are the exact opposite. So if I posted a link you can counter that link with an alternate study.

      The question then becomes; who benefits from what study? IF the numbers in favor of public prisons are true the only ones to benefit are the US tax payers, if the numbers of the contrary are true t More..

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (0)

    • Well, I appreciate your candor. I don't consider myself sufficiently educated on the subject to make a financial stand one way or the other. What got me going was the assertion that the government was good and capable and the private sector was greedy and corrupt. The truth is somewhere in between. Make no mistake, the government is plenty capable of fostering vested interests and showing the love to those that support them. Otherwise known as supply and demand with profits included. Just More..

      Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

      (0)

    • Don't mistake my argument as me being some gullible chump that thinks the Government can't do no wrong. But that said I stand behind my statement that the government is held to account in far greater terms by the American people then and private business could ever be.

      And as for the post office, If the private sector can do it cheaper and still have a high standard of not hiring those with criminal records, and scanning packages for Anthrax etc. then show me the way, I'd use them instead.

      A More..

      Posted Mar-29-2011 By 

      (1)

  • Stay out of jail and you won't have to worry about it.

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (-4)

  • Like this comment will not be deleted, but the moral of the story is Do not be an asshole and stay out of jail and you will not catch a bad case of rotyourcockoff.

    Next Case!

    Posted Mar-28-2011 By 

    (-6)