Safe Mode: On
Israel, Syria, and the double standards of the Free World

By Carlo Strenger , Haaretz,08.02.12







I have for years opposed Israel’s occupation of the West Bank, and I continue to be appalled by Israel’s continuing expansion of settlements. But I'm running into a linguistic problem: if I use ‘appalled’ for Israel’s treatment of Palestinians, what term is left for Assad’s butchering of his own people for almost a year?



It would be of great importance for Israel’s more one-sided critics to acknowledge, once in a while, that Israel is located in a pretty rough neighborhood. Israel’s citizens would feel a bit more understood, if these critics were to express sympathy for Israel’s genuine, if flawed, attempt to maintain a liberal democracy in the midst of regimes that often commit outrageous crimes against humanity. At times, when I hear some of the critical comments on Israel, one might think that Israel is Belgium, and that for unintelligible reasons it keeps attacking helpless Luxembourg.







Because Israel’s precarious situation is rarely acknowledged, many Israelis end up voting for boorish people like Lieberman whose basic attitude is inspired by Putin: the Free World’s hand-wringing, he believes, is nothing but a sham, hypocrisy thinly disguised as moral outrage when it comes to Israel, and acquiescence to the inevitable when it comes to the surrounding Islamic countries. The world, he claims, made a huge fuss when Israel stopped the Mavi Marmara and, unfortunately, killed nine of its passengers, but chose to ignore that the Turkish Army killed many Kurds at the same time.



The automatic response of some of Israel’s left-leaning critics both in the U.S. and Europe is predictable: how does Assad’s butchering of his compatriots justify the occupation?



My answer is: it doesn’t. But Israel’s critics would do well for the sake of fairness and integrity to acknowledge that it quite frightening to live in a neighborhood in which dictators kill at the scale of the Assad family. Because Israelis wonder: what if these guys, one day, win against us? What exactly will they do to women and children here, if they kill their own? And some of Israel’s critics conveniently forget that Hamas, which in the past won Palestinian elections, has been Assad’s protégé until it decided recently that it is wiser for it not to be seen as supporting him.



I assume that some of my readers might be surprised to read this blog post and wonder: has he finally snapped? Has he gone over to the right?



The answer is no: my positions have remained essentially the same: I think that Israel’s post-1967 policies have been a disaster, and I think that Ben-Gurion was right in predicting that holding on to the territories would endanger Israel’s future. But, given the situation since the Second Intifada, I continue to think that the fears of ordinary Israelis are quite understandable.

Most Israelis are not ideological right-wingers. To this day two-thirds of Israel’s Jews believe that the two-state solution is the only chance for peace. But they are afraid to move ahead with it: what will happen if we go for the two-state solution, and Hamas, vowing to destroy Israel, will come to power again?



They want assurances that scenarios like the shelling of southern Israel will not be repeated in Israel’s heartland; and nobody can give such assurances as long as Hamas doesn’t explicitly renounce armed struggle against Israel and recognize Israel’s legitimacy.



I judge Israel by the standards of the Free World, and I want no other standard to be applied to it. I am happy that Israel is seen as part of the Free World, and not compared to countries that freely murder their own citizens.

But watching the utter horror of Assad’s genocidal actions, it becomes understandable why many Israelis feel that indeed the world is applying a double standard; that the condemnation of Israel and that of the countries around it are in no proportion with each other.



I wish nothing more than an Israel that conforms to the moral standard of the Free World. But even here there is a certain amount of double standard: Israel’s targeted killings of terrorist suspects are often attacked as outrageous. But Obama, a leader whom I greatly respect, has approved of targeted killings at a scale never even envisaged by Israel, and I haven’t heard much protest. For some reason it seems quite acceptable if the drones killing members of al-Qaida in Yemen are directed from Langley, Virginia, whereas drones killing those planning terror attacks in Israel are criticized if they are directed from Tel Aviv.



This being said, Israel’s current government has made it well nigh impossible for the Free World to have empathy for Israeli fears. Nobody in the Free World believes that Israel’s rational concerns justify the maintenance of isolated settlements; nobody accepts Israel making Palestinian lives miserable at checkpoints for the sake of the security for a few starry eyed settlers who are convinced that every stone in the West Bank is eternally promised to Jews.

And the behavior of our government doesn’t help either: Time and again I hear from Western politicians, diplomats and commentators how utterly outlandish Lieberman behaves; time and again they tell me how unreliable Netanyahu is. They are unimpressed by Netanyahu’s constant harping on the Holocaust theme; they see Lieberman as a kind of freak of the international diplomatic scene, and avoid meeting him if they can.



Hence, while the Free World’s excessive tendency to condemn Israel for its actions must be analyzed in depth, and in some cases condemned, we must not let the Netanyahu government off the hook: its intransigence and lack of civility greatly contribute to the Free World’s dwindling understanding of Israel’s difficult predicament.












http://www.haaretz.com/blogs/strenger-than-fiction/israel-syria-and-the-double-standards-of-the-free-world-1.411724


Added: Feb-8-2012 Occurred On: Feb-8-2012
By: aydeo
In:
Other Middle East
Tags: Strenger, West, Double standarts, Assad, One sided critics
Views: 4626 | Comments: 32 | Votes: 0 | Favorites: 1 | Shared: 0 | Updates: 0 | Times used in channels: 1
You need to be registered in order to add comments! Register HERE
Sort by: Newest first | Oldest first | Highest score first
Liveleak opposes racial slurs - if you do spot comments that fall into this category, please report them for us to review.
  • There IS no Palestine.
    The sand-monkey's were driven out by Jordan because even the other ayrab's don't want the Asshole's.
    Palestine like izzlam, is a vile lie, and a curse.

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (0) | Report

  • You assume to much in that Israel is being condemned at all by the "free world". I and millions and millions more like me see Israel as a unified country under attack and defending itself against a religion that feels jews (and christians) should be removed from the face of the earth. Syria is in the midst of a civil war where it's citizens are anything but unified and wish to overthrow it's oppressive government. To compare the two is like comparing apples to orangutans(Maybe a bit un More..

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (0) | Report

  • Peace is not happening, forget it.
    Both sides have good excuses to blame the other and there is only one Ron Paul.

    In order to have peace in Middle East, we'd need about 8 Ron Pauls.

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (0) | Report

  • Has Israel scheduled the next Gaza Massacre yet?

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (0) | Report

  • Comment of user 'JToKKo' has been deleted by author (after account deletion)!
  • well said Carlo.
    But no, the "outsiders" will never know what it is like living here.

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (0) | Report

  • what about the illegal block aid on gaza for over a year? illegal settelments? palestinans are in a big jail lol i hate assad but israel is no better. P.S are the isralies going to give syria the golan back?

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (0) | Report

  • Carlo Strenger usually writes against Israel current policies in his blog, so any attempt to portray him as a Zionist supporter or other shit like that will be very lame.

    This is specailly for ED and some of his buddies here, who prefer to deall every day with every and each fart some brainless settler kids are doing, and total ignore places like Syria...


    * The picture shows the death toll in Syria since the sart of the uprising there.

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (-1) | Report

    • @aydeo Considering the fact that the 'free-world' has slapped massive sanctions on Syria, threatened it with the possibility of war and told Assad to stand down...where is the double-standard?

      Israel faces nothing even close to the co-ordinated Intl action taken against both Assad and Ghadaffi prior

      Beyond this, Israel is many ways a European State in the Middle East. Thus Westerners tend to judge it by Western standards and not Assad's standards (which are non-existent).
      Its really that simpl More..

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (1) | Report

    • @ElegantDecline

      No, it's not- I'm not talking here about the governments (And so is Mr. Strenger)

      On the contrary- the western gov. has all the rights to put pressure on my gov.

      We are talking about the different reaction of people like you (you are not the only one but you represent them here, just as I represent the Left in Israel), who have no problem calling themselves 'Liberals' but in fact are 'liberals' only when it comes to Israel policies (or the American ones in some cases), but t More..

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (0) | Report

  • Comment of user 'Blue3tar' has been deleted by author (after account deletion)!
  • It's easy for us as Americans to sit back and criticize Israels actions... But imagine for a second that America wasn't bordered by Canada and Mexico but rather bordered by countries who called for he destruction of America and lobbed rockets over the border.. Those countries would be occupied almost immediately by America... But we criticize Israel for doing far less than what us Americans would do in the same situation... If Mexico's president came out tomorrow and called for the destruction o More..

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (-2) | Report

    • @seanwoody716 Its a really dumb comparison because America was envisaged and built as an 'anti-colonial' power (Indians aside). While Israel is knowingly taking privately owned land on the West Bank in order to move its own people in.

      But are you really surprised that Comanche and Apache's raided homesteads and massacred people?

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (1) | Report

    • @seanwoody716 Is it really easy to criticize Israels actions? I see the actions of Israel strictly as self defense.

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (-1) | Report

    • @Pure_Adrenaline No it's not easy for me to criticize Israels actions and i'm with you... But it sure seems easy for allot of people blame the tension on Israel's "occupation" of the west bank.. Such as Obummas administration which has clearly tries to tie the hands of Israel to create "peace" with muslims who don't want it..

      I guess i mainly refer to our people in office rather than the average American citizen (i should have been more specific)

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (-1) | Report

    • @ElegantDecline I wasn't making a direct comparison.. I was stating if Mexico was hypothetically (key word hypothetical) being actively aggressive on a large scale such as Palestinians (i.e lobbing rockets across the border) we would not allow it and American citizens would expect nothing less.

      Obviously you cannot make a comparison based on how things are in reality today as Mexico does not do these things (the cartels do on a smaller scale but its not supported by the majority of the populati More..

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (-1) | Report

    • @ElegantDecline well said!

      Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

      (0) | Report

  • More extreme leftist bullshit from Haaretz.

    He takes a valid argument and uses it for political gain.

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (-3) | Report

  • Nuke Iran,Syria,China,Russia = Better world.

    Posted Feb-8-2012 By 

    (-6) | Report