Safe Mode: On
Court Upholds Domestic Drone Use in Arrest of American Citizen

A North Dakota court has preliminarily upheld the first-ever use of an unmanned drone to assist in the arrest of an American citizen.

A judge denied a request to dismiss charges Wednesday against Rodney Brossart, a man arrested last year after a 16-hour standoff with police at his Lakota, N.D., ranch. Brossart's lawyer argued that law enforcement's "warrantless use of [an] unmanned military-like surveillance aircraft" and "outrageous governmental conduct" warranted dismissal of the case, according to court documents obtained by U.S. News.

[Thomas Paine and Ben Franklin: You Didn't Build That]

District Judge Joel Medd wrote that "there was no improper use of an unmanned aerial vehicle" and that the drone "appears to have had no bearing on these charges being contested here," according to the documents.

Court records state that last June, six cows wandered onto Brossart's 3,000 acre farm, about 60 miles west of Grand Forks. Brossart allegedly refused to return the cows, which led to a long, armed standoff with the Grand Forks police department. At some point during the standoff, Homeland Security, through an agreement with local police, offered up the use of an unmanned predator drone, which "was used for surveillance," according to the court documents.

Grand Forks SWAT team chief Bill Macki said in an interview that the drone was used to ensure Brossart and his family members, who were also charged, didn't leave the farm and were unarmed during the arresting raid.

[FAA Releases List of Registered Drone Operators]

Brossart faces felony terrorizing and theft of property charges and a misdemeanor criminal mischief charge. Although his charges weren't dismissed, Brossart won a motion to move the trial from Nelson County—which has a population of 3,100—to nearby Grand Forks County.

Brossart is believed to be the only American citizen who was arrested with the assistance of a drone on U.S. soil. John Villasenor, of the Washington, D.C.-based Brookings Institution, says the legality of domestic drone use likely stems from two Supreme Court cases that allow police to use "public, navigable airspace" for evidence gathering.

Domestic drone use has become a controversial topic over the past several months, with Congress directing the Federal Aviation Administration to devise guidelines for proper drone use.

[The Coming Drone Revolution: What You Should Know]

Wednesday, Massachusetts Democrat Rep. Edward Markey released a draft of a bill that would require private drone operators to inform the government of any data collected by drones and would require law enforcement to "minimize the collection … of information and data unrelated to the investigation of a crime."

States are "increasingly using unmanned aircraft systems in the United States, including deployments for law enforcement operations," according to the bill. There "is the potential for unmanned aircraft system technology to enable invasive and pervasive surveillance without adequate privacy protections."

In April, Brossart told U.S. News that he thought the SWAT team use of the drone was "definitely" illegal. Some estimates suggest that there may be as many as 30,000 unmanned drones operated in the United States by 2020 for uses such as wildfire containment and surveillance, law enforcement, and surveying.

Jason Koebler is a science and technology reporter for U.S. News & World Report. You can follow him on Twitter or reach him at jkoebler@usnews.com.


Added: Oct-2-2012 Occurred On: Oct-2-2012
By: Pakistan_Has_Nukes
In:
Regional News
Tags: Court, Upholds, Domestic, Drone, Use, in, Arrest, of, American, Citizen
Location: United States (load item map)
Marked as: approved
Views: 1296 | Comments: 35 | Votes: 0 | Favorites: 0 | Shared: 0 | Updates: 0 | Times used in channels: 2
You need to be registered in order to add comments! Register HERE
Sort by: Newest first | Oldest first | Highest score first
Liveleak opposes racial slurs - if you do spot comments that fall into this category, please report them for us to review.
  • We should pass a law that a drone be assigned to watch every congressman and senate member for life....in the name of national security of course. Should be on a public feed so everyone can see everything they do all day.

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (5)

  • why are they arguing about using drones being illegal when this guy had a 16 hour standoff with police?

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (3)

  • All of you hollering about drones didn't say a boo when cops started using helicopters - so what is the difference?

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (3)

  • isn't america great. we test weapons on the enemy then on our own people. land of the free my ass. we have no right to privacy no right to bear arms and no right to peace and enjoyment. this is not the country my forfathers fought for.

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (2)

  • Domestic drones are domestic terrorism.

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (1)

  • Our freedom is going out the window pretty soon we wont be able to fuck a chic in the back yard without a drone putting it on liveleak LOL!

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (1)

  • Give back the cows idiot.

    Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

    (1)

  • Even if you're one of the paranoid masses that believe there's a drone over your house watching you, who cares? Don't get into a standoff with the police over some stupid shit like stealing wandering cattle and threatening human lives over it, and don't murder anyone or steal anything and you won't have to worry about it. On a related note: I legally put 300 rounds downrange in my backyard this morning and not one Hellfire was shot at me!

    Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

    (1)

  • 10,000 drones with bombs for Afghanistan and Pakistan. Kill 'em all, let Allah sort 'em out.

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (0)

  • Welcome to no-more-freedom America. The feds or whoever will have a drone in the sky 24/7 watching everything everybody does, won't like what they see, and will punish you to one degree or another.
    It's a good time to be old in the USA if you ask me. Old enough to remember what it was like to be free.

    Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

    (0)

    • @Eva_Destruction It's a good time to be a paranoid loon listening to Alex Jones. If you were even slightly rational, you would see that this case is a clear example of how these drones are legitimate.

      Without the drone, they would have done the exact same thing with a helicopter, and the only difference is that it would have cost a lot more money.

      It takes a lot of blind ego to pretend to believe that you'll have a drone dedicated to following you.

      Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

      (2)

    • @ST0N3PONY You'd be wrong, because they'll be tracking almost EVERYBODY.

      Posted Oct-6-2012 By 

      (0)

    • @Eva_Destruction Okay... Tell Alex Jones I said hi. Don't let the scary black helicopters get you.

      Posted Oct-6-2012 By 

      (0)

  • If your not doing anything wrong why worry about something that catches crooks and terrorists ? Why didn't he return the friggin' cows ? What a dick ! I'm glad he's not my neighbor.

    Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

    (0)

  • Americans reserve the right to shoot them down...

    Especially if they trespass onto their property...

    Property belongs to the people not the federal government..

    Shoot them down...

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (-2)

  • Comment of user 'DirtyUncleBerty' has been deleted by author!
    • @DirtyUncleBerty I realize you're not very bright, but, why exactly do you have a problem with this case or the decision?

      This is where you drool on yourself and refuse to answer because you didn't even read it and don't know anything about it.

      Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

      (0)

    • Comment of user 'DirtyUncleBerty' has been deleted by author!
    • @DirtyUncleBerty "This is where you drool on yourself and refuse to answer because you didn't even read it and don't know anything about it."

      Yeah, exactly. Thanks. Typical mindless liberal tool. Keep parroting more tired dipshit liberal buzzwords buddy. It's all you can do.

      Thank you for proving me right. A simple straight answer would have proved me wrong, but, you're incapable. So instead you spew a bunch of retarded nonsense. A simple straight answer also would have been shorter. More..

      Posted Oct-3-2012 By 

      (2)

  • First you kill other people with drones, then you kill American citizens and his American son outside of America with a drone, then you start using them as spy planes.In about 4-6 years, drones will start having some sort of pinpong ball attack, which will gradually evolve into gunfire.

    Who's the barbarians now, America? My country has drones too, but they will never use it against us.

    Posted Oct-2-2012 By 

    (-3)