Safe Mode: On
Britain's love affair with our military is dangerous

As soldiers become more visible in public life, debate about why they are dying – and killing – in Afghanistan is disappearing.

George Chesterton
guardian.co.uk,

Friday 23 December 2011 11.00 GMT



Alexandra Burke performs at the Help For Heroes concert in 2010. Photograph: Dave J Hogan/Getty Images



The only place you could be sure of seeing a British soldier
used to be outside a pub in a garrison town at chucking-out time. Now
there are soldiers on talent shows, parading in sports stadiums and
singing on daytime television. The narrative is always the same:
sacrifice, suffering, redemption. As individual tales they can be
inspirational, but what they represent collectively is more worrying.

Britain has been drawn into a deep sleep about war and nowhere is this
slumber more pernicious than in the militarisation of popular culture.Dedicated
servicemen and women should be respected and those who suffer deserve
the very best support and care. But it is our fault we allowed our
politicians to send them to conflicts that served little purpose other
than to cling on to some amorphous notion of national power. Now the
debate about why they are still dying – and killing – in Afghanistan has
disappeared from public life. Instead, an acceptance that the military
is an agent for good has become the norm, and we are told to love our
soldiers as if they are members of an extended family.

This year, from the The X Factor to football, from Radio 2 to the tabloids,
we have been encouraged to welcome the military into our homes and
hearts. There are, potentially terrible, consequences for this love
affair.This month, BBC4's America in Pictures: The Story of Life Magazine
interviewed photojournalists working between the 1940s and 1960s. Most
striking was the uncompromising honesty of their picture essays of war.
These stark and provocative images were so different to the sanitised
and cowardly portrayal of war in British media over the past 10 years.
Imagine how the Daily Mail would react if the BBC showed pictures of
Britons face down in the Helmand mud on the Six o'clock news.Tough questions about a conflict that has cost, at the time of writing, 344 British combat deaths have been replaced by an invitation to demonstrate our gratitude to the military (BBC3's Our War
aside).

But what we are supposed to be grateful for has rarely, if
ever, been mentioned in 2011. It's as if, in a scary and bankrupt world,
we've been invited to take consolation wherever we can find it. In this
case our consolation is the last refuge of the scoundrel. It's easier
than thinking about a decade of fighting that has cost billions of
pounds and at least 30,000 Afghan lives, and let's not forget six years
in Iraq during which 100,000 people died.We have turned the
reality of war into an emotionally nourishing theatre – this year the
home-counties Valhalla, Wootton Bassett, was rewarded with royal
patronage for its role at the vanguard of our delusion.

A key part of this is the politically stultifying Help for Heroes campaign, which, of
course, serves an ideological and financial function for a broke
government.It's no coincidence that we are being chaperoned down
this path amid economic gloom. On the X Factor serving soldiers emerged
from behind a hydra of desperate contestants – the sound of military
drums accompanying karaoke singers is the sound of a nation battening
down the hatches. If David Bowie's Heroes can be dressed up as a paean
to the British army then anything can.

The convenient marriage of sport and the military has been a boon to jingoism and apathy for a
succession of US administrations. This is where we are heading. The
kerfuffle over the Football Association's request to adorn England
players' shirts with poppies – which Fifa rejected Johnny
Foreigner-style, until Prince William (Sandhurst, Blues and Royals, RAF)
intervened – confirmed the prejudice abroad that we (in this case the
English) are bombastic and backward-looking.This month Radio 2 has promoted the Military Wives choir's single, Wherever You Are.

There is no argument against the good intentions of those who want to
help injured or ill soldiers, but in cultural terms this is sickly icing
on the Christmas cake for a year in which the public have been taught
to love those who fight but not to hate the fact that they are still
fighting, 10 years on, with little more to show for it than the dead and
injured on both sides. Worthy though the appearance of a soldier on a
TV Christmas special is, it is a deeply political one if his
participation in the war, and therefore the war itself, is portrayed as
unquestionably good.If the presence of the military becomes
normal, then war, for those at home anyway, becomes normal, especially
as attitudes to non-conformity harden into a jackboot of public outrage.

It is the government's responsibility to look after the soldiers it sends
to war, but it is our responsibility to stop the government sending them
out to die in the first place. If we blindly endorse the goodness of
the military we are in danger of forfeiting our ability to stop wars, or
better still, prevent them from starting.


Added: Dec-23-2011 Occurred On: Dec-23-2011
By: allyssa
In:
Other News
Tags: military, bootlicking, uniform worship, UK
Location: United Kingdom (UK/GB) (load item map)
Views: 3149 | Comments: 63 | Votes: 0 | Favorites: 0 | Shared: 0 | Updates: 0 | Times used in channels: 2
You need to be registered in order to add comments! Register HERE
Sort by: Newest first | Oldest first | Highest score first
Liveleak opposes racial slurs - if you do spot comments that fall into this category, please report them for us to review.
  • I love my troops & I love my nation, not arsed what some Guardian journalist thinks.

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (9) | Report

  • Comment of user 'Documentary2011' has been deleted by author (after account deletion)!
  • Oh stfu.

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (7) | Report

  • This post is shit. I would like to see if "allyssa" could do what our troops or troops from the U.K. could do.

    Disrespect them all you want, because you will never have my respect. I know you don't care, but the people in Afghanistan are some of the toughest guys alive and I find it hilarious how you stereotype all soldiers as stupid and incompetent.

    Some of those guys are smarter than you FOR SURE, and ALL OF THEM are stronger than you, physically, mentally, and emotionally.

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (5) | Report

    • @cswartz Well said my friend...well said!

      Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

      (5) | Report

    • @cswartz
      Tell me why we are fighting in Afghanistan?

      Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

      (-7) | Report

    • @allyssa
      Still waiting on the answer from "cswartz" as to why we are fighting in Afghanistan?
      I'm guessing he doesn't know...

      Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

      (-7) | Report

    • @Birdy you blocked me, wanker! fuckin lol

      Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

      (0) | Report

    • @allyssa
      I'm sorry. I got home from school after making up a math quiz that made me tired. I fell asleep just after 6 p.m. and I just got up because I was exhausted.

      First of all, let me say how funny it is that you are 'still waiting' for my response in the same hour you asked me.

      But to answer your question, we are in Afghanistan to fight an insurgency presence and do more to stabilize the government so that when we leave, the Afghans will be able to take care of themselves.
      We originally More..

      Posted Dec-24-2011 By 

      (0) | Report

  • how miserable are these left wing scumbags? LOL! hate and intolerance, the values of the liberal left.

    kill them all.

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (4) | Report

  • they banned british soldiers from bing in public because of the ira dum dum dum

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (3) | Report

  • Pure shit...look where it's coming from...a piece of shit newspaper.

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (3) | Report

  • "... debate about why they are dying – and killing – in Afghanistan is disappearing."

    What that really means is, "I want everyone at each other's throats because the Afghan war is WRONNNNNNGGGGGGGG!!!"

    Maybe so, but I suspect the only thing "dangerous" about "disappearing debate" in this case is that it causes righteous amoral agony to slimy narcissistic so-called "journalists."

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (2) | Report

  • i disagree with your neck down comments girl my brothers are squaddies and bloody good they are to. my cousins are squaddies infact out of fourteen only two havn't served.
    but i agree they should not be plastered all over the tv.
    they are not propaganda to be wheeled out when needed because people ask questions.
    i love our boys serving in the military, but i do not respect them.
    "were only following orders" is they're cry but as i say how many germans claimed that as we marched them to More..

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (1) | Report

  • War is like a bicycle,..it gets easier the more you do it.

    But that also goes for about everything else.

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (0) | Report

  • whats sad about england is that 95 % of the men care more about football than how the uk is being run ,never mind the fact that are boys are fighting .i was talking to this guy the other day about N korea and what may or may not happen but he was like so what .i said to him but what if it ended up as ww3 and 100,000s of are troops die and he said i could not give a rats ass ....... sad

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (0) | Report

  • It's not that bad. Here's an interesting tidbit I found using Google earth, it's a unique feature easily found around almost every US town: outdoor (civilian) firing ranges. They're everywhere. I didn't realize that was unique until I started seeing it. Seems obvious with hindsight. Makes me proud.
    There seems to be a critical size though. If the town is small enough, the whole place is an impromptu firing range.
    Even though we speak roughly the same language... there's a huge divide.

    Posted Dec-24-2011 By 

    (0) | Report

  • They're not heroes , 99% are numpties who want to shoot somebody with impunity .

    Posted Dec-23-2011 By 

    (-12) | Report